How to Reinvest Dividends: 3 Pros, 3 Cons

Dividend reinvestment is one of the most powerful weapons in the income investor’s toolbox. You’ve probably heard it said that compound interest is the most powerful force in the universe (a quote attributed to Einstein, almost certainly erroneously); well, dividend reinvestment takes advantage of some of the same forces—namely time and compounding. First, let me tell you how to reinvest dividends, and discuss some of the advantages and drawbacks of doing so.

Three Reasons to Reinvest Your Dividends

When you choose to reinvest your dividends, each stock’s dividend payment is used to buy new shares of the same stock at the market rate. You then start earning dividends on those new shares, and those dividends get turned into more shares, and so on and so forth.

Over time, the number of shares you own and the size of the dividend checks you receive every quarter will both gradually increase, without you doing a thing. (And this doesn’t take into account when stocks hike their dividends—which are the stocks I focus on in my Cabot Dividend Investor advisory.)

key to success dollar sign

Special Offer:
Try Cabot Dividend Investor for Just $1

What if I told you that you could pay JUST A DOLLAR to start an entire portfolio comprised of market-beating stocks that could help you build long-lasting wealth and position you for a comfortable retirement?

Would that interest you?

If so, click here to learn more.

Most brokers will reinvest your dividends for you for free, and the purchases will be completed without fees (although you will owe taxes on the dividend amount).

Alternatively, you can often sign up for a Dividend Reinvestment Plan, or DRIP, directly with the dividend-paying company. Company-operated DRIPs allow investors to buy shares directly from the company, and in exchange, dividends are automatically reinvested in the company’s stock, sometimes at below-market prices.

Those are the two most obvious benefits of dividend reinvesting: You can increase your position for free, without fees, and it’s automatic, so you don’t have to think about it.

If a stock is high quality and you plan to own it for a long time, dividend reinvestment is a great passive way to increase your exposure over time. Sure, you could collect the dividends and then manually invest them in something else, but a good habit that takes no effort is easier to keep up than one that takes a little effort.

However, the third big reason to reinvest dividends, and the less obvious one, is actually the most powerful. It’s the power of compounding, the same action that makes compound interest so powerful.

When you reinvest dividends, you increase the size of your investment, thus also increasing the dividends you’ll receive next time. So each reinvestment will be slightly larger than the last (assuming dividend payments don’t decrease). Just as with compound interest, you’ll be surprised how quickly those little additions can add up!

For example, let’s say you own 100 shares of a $40 stock with a 2.5% yield. That means the company pays $1.00 per share in dividends each year, or 25 cents per quarter. This table shows how your dividend income and the size of your investment will change over the first year.

Knowing how to reinvest dividends helps your investments compound without doing anything.

As you can see, reinvesting that first $25 increases your second dividend payment by 16 cents, because you now own another $25 worth of dividend-paying stock. By the end of the year, your quarterly dividends have increased to $25.47, and the value of your investment has increased by $100.94—that $100 is simply the dividend payments, which you would have earned whether or not you chose to reinvest. But the extra 94 cents is “dividends on dividends,” which you earned thanks to reinvesting.

Ninety-four cents may not seem like a lot, which is why the second important force at work here is time. In the 10th year, your annual dividend income from this same position will be $126.31, up from $100.94 the first year. (That’s a yield on cost of 3.16%, based on your initial investment.) The value of your investment will be $5,132.11, without any appreciation in the stock price.

One-hundred thirty-two dollars and eleven cents of that is thanks to your dividends on dividends. (If you hadn’t reinvested, the value of your investment would still be $4,000, and you would have collected $1,000 in dividends, for a total return of $5,000. The difference between that and $5,132.11 is what we’re calling dividends on dividends.)

After 30 years, your investment will be worth $8,448.26, and you’ll be earning $207.95 per year in dividends—you’ve more than doubled your original income stream, and are earning a yield on cost of 5.2%.

And that’s all without a single increase in the stock price or boost in the dividend. If you buy a Dividend Aristocrat that increases its dividend every year, your returns improve at every step.

If the company in the example above increases its dividend by 5% per year, your annual income will reach $200 at the end of 10 years, instead of 30. After 30 years, your annual income will be a whopping $2,218.83, and your investment will be worth $22,022.24. Not bad for a stock that doesn’t go up!

Of course, if you buy a stock that does goes up over 30 years (as most of them do!) you’ll be even happier. While your reinvestments will occur at higher prices, the capital appreciation on those new shares more than makes up for it. (If you’re intrigued, search for a dividend reinvestment calculator online and punch in some real numbers.)

3 Reasons Not to Reinvest Your Dividends

While dividend reinvestment is powerful, and knowing how to reinvest dividends is important, there are a couple of reasons why you might not want to reinvest your dividends.

The most obvious reason is that you need the income. If you’re in the “distribution” phase of your investing life, dividends are a perfect source of passive income.

Income from qualified dividends is taxed at the long-term capital gains rate (currently 15% for investors who are in the 25% to 35% tax bracket for ordinary income, 0% for taxpayers in a lower bracket and 20% for those in the highest bracket).

So if you’re going to be looking to your portfolio for income every month anyway, it makes sense to have that cash deposited in your account.

You might also choose to stop reinvesting your dividends for allocation reasons. Reinvesting your dividends will cause your stock positions to grow over time, and if you’ve owned a particular stock for a long time, it may already be a large enough percentage of your portfolio.

Higher-yielding positions will grow faster, which can throw your allocations out of whack pretty quickly. So once a stock position is as big as you want it to get (for now) feel free to turn off dividend reinvestment for that position, and either enjoy the extra income or save up the cash to invest in other stocks.

Lastly, you may also have stock-specific reasons not to reinvest dividends—if a stock is temporarily overvalued, or you simply don’t want to buy any more of it at current prices.

The Power of Knowing How to Reinvest Dividends

But, bottom line, reinvesting dividends is a surprisingly powerful tool to passively improve your investment returns, as long as it fits with your investing goals. Now that you know how to reinvest dividends, I’ll let you make that call!

*Note: This piece was reprinted from an issue of Cabot Dividend Investor, which focuses on presenting investments that offer consistent income to its readers. Each month, Chloe tackles an aspect of income investing that’s important to her subscribers. If you’re interested in joining Cabot Dividend Investor, click here.

Chloe Lutts Jensen, Chief Analyst, Cabot Dividend Investor

Retired or Thinking About Retirement?

Chloe Lutts Jensen developed Cabot's proprietary Individualized Retirement Income System (IRIS) and Cabot Dividend Investor to provide both high income and peace of mind. If you’re retired or thinking about retirement, her advisory is designed for you.

 

Learn More

Comments

You must be logged in to post a comment.