Momentum Investing vs. Value Investing: You Don't Have to Choose Just One - Cabot Wealth Network

Momentum Investing vs. Value Investing: You Don’t Have to Choose Just One

Momentum investing is a powerful thing, data shows.

There’s a great divide between momentum investing vs. value investing. But you can incorporate aspects of both into the stocks you look for.

From a young age I was fascinated with investing, and my father taught me everything he knows.

He was a large-cap portfolio manager who managed a billion-dollar portfolio for institutions looking to invest in value stocks.

I looked up to my father (still do!) and soaked up everything he taught me about investing.

His approach was to look for securities that the market had written off due to temporary “issues.”

Eventually, the “issues” are resolved and the unloved value stocks recover to generate an attractive return.

best stocks september

5 Best Stocks to Buy in September


Find out which stocks you should buy this month to make money in this changing market.

While my father was my first mentor, I adopted several other “virtual” mentors over time. Warren Buffett was one of them, and I read everything that I could about him.

One of Buffett’s famous quotes is, “Price is what you pay, value is what you get.”

In other words, spend your time understanding the business and trying to estimate its intrinsic value.

This is the approach that I adopted.

But the more time I spend in the market, the more I’ve grown to appreciate momentum investing.

The Power of Momentum Investing

I don’t know why momentum works, but it does, and has been working for a long time.

O’Shaughnessy Asset Management (OSAM) looked at all stocks from 1964 to 2017 and concluded that high momentum stocks outperform low momentum stocks.

Specifically, the first decile of high momentum stocks generated annualized excess returns of 4.3% while the bottom decile of high momentum stocks generated annualized excess returns of -8.2%.

Momentum investing pays, as the bar on the far left shows.

Two Centuries Investments looked back even further (all the way to 1825!) and had the same conclusion.

Let’s take a step back and define “momentum.”

In a nutshell, momentum means that stocks that have outperformed (over six months or 12 months) tend to continue to do so. On the other hand, stocks that have underperformed also continue to do so.

Given this data and my new appreciation for it, momentum is an important factor that I consider when picking stocks.

Many investors have asked how to identify high momentum stocks.

The best way to do so is to simply browse stocks that are trading at a 52-week high. Here’s a good free resource to do so.

Momentum Investing vs. Value Investing: How About Both?!

But I don’t believe in using momentum in isolation.

My ideal stock is one that has the following six characteristics:

  • Fast growth
  • Cheap valuation
  • High insider ownership
  • Reasonable balance sheet
  • Low share count (under 30 million shares outstanding)
  • High momentum.

My new appreciation for momentum has also gotten me more comfortable with averaging up or buying more shares of a stock that has appreciated (if I still believe it’s ultimately undervalued).

IDT Corp (IDT) (disclosure: I am long IDT) is a perfect example.

I first recommended IDT to my Cabot Micro-Cap Insider subscribers at 19.47 per share in this February. At the time the stock was at a 52-week high and had all six characteristics that I look for.

Despite being at 52-week highs when I recommended it, the stock is up 167% since then, and still satisfies all six characteristics on my checklist, so I have no plans to sell.

If you don’t already, you may want to consider incorporating momentum into your investment process. It will help you find winners like IDT.

And if you want to know what other micro-cap stocks I’m currently recommending – all of which have similar blends of momentum and value, and boast an average return of 67% – you can become a Cabot Micro-Cap Insider subscriber by clicking here.

Rich Howe

Micro-Cap Expert Rich Howe

Rich is a trained economist who brings his decades of investing experience to bear on finding the best micro-cap stocks in the market. Get his picks by subscribing to Cabot Micro-Cap Insider.

Learn More >>


  • Rich H.

    Thanks for the question, Victor. I would say the three big lessons that I learned from my father are:
    1) Concentrate your portfolio on your best investments. He ran a concentrated portfolio of his 10 best ideas and it always outperformed the more diversified portfolio.
    2) Value works, but wait to buy value stocks until they start to generate better results. In other words, don’t just buy “down and out companies” because they can stay very cheap for a long time.
    3) Start your own business. It’s the best way to build wealth (this last one is not specific to investing, but it’s something that I’ve taken to heart).

  • Victor H.

    Rich: Thanks for telling us about your dad and his lifetime in the stock market value sector. Could you share a few of his thoughts with us? Thanks so much! …….. Victor

You must log in to post a comment.

Enter Your Log In Credentials

This setting should only be used on your home or work computer.

Need Assistance?

call Cabot Wealth Network Customer Service at

(800) 326-8826

Send this to a friend